Super Bowl Recipes & Nutella Cream Pie!

I was originally going to just post Super Bowl recipes today but then I realized tomorrow is Nutella Day!! So, clearly I had to whip up something delicious! So, this post is killing two birds with one stone….except it ends up being three because February is Pie Month and I made a……….drumroll please……………Nutella Cream Pie! But before we totally get into the pie nutella situation, lets talk Super Bowl Food!

I’m going to list a few of your favorites that my family happens to love and then some others from food blogs I follow!

1. The Freshest 9-Layer Dip from Lauren’s Latest
2. Spicy Texas Ranch Filled Biscuits from Lauren’s Latest
3. Crispy Cheese Pulled Pork Tacos with Sesame Slaw from Lauren’s Latest
4. Pomegranate Salsa from Lauren’s Latest

Of course there are the last two recipes I posted as well: Sweet Potato Nacho Fries and Crunchy Caramel Munch Mix. YUM!

Now here’s a list of different snacks and treats from some of the most talented bloggers out there! All of these make me drool!

1. Buffalo Chicken Dip {doesn’t that just sound so good?!} from Brown Eyed Baker {always posts recipes I drool over!}

2. Cookies and Cream Rice Crispy Treats from Picky Palate {one of the nicest people!}

3. Fish & Chips from Dine and Dish {Ok, Kristen is really nice too!}

4. Thick Oven-Baked Chili from Barbara Bakes {Barbara befriended me when I was a no one and my blog was teeny tiny! Still sort of am teeny tiny, but working on it! That reminds me– follow me on Twitter and Facebook! You know you want to!}

5. Chex Mix Arare from La Fuji Mama {I don’t know Rachael very well, but I think we’d be friends. She seems super sweet. Go stop by and say hi to her!}

6. Marshmallow Crunch Brownie Bars from La Due & Crew {a fun new blog I just found! 🙂 }

7. Homemade Pizza Rolls from Tidy Mom {So talented in so many ways! Love her!}

8. Peanut Butter Cream Pie from The Peche {Not very Super-Bowlie, but I love that this couple have just been posting pie recipes lately! I heart pie. Scroll down for Nutella Cream Pie!}

9. Cheesy Chicken, Avocado and Bacon Quesadillas from Kevin and Amanda {Do these not sound amazing?! I’ll be making these}

10. Spicy Pepperoni Pizza with Caramelized Onions from Two Peas and their Pod {Maria is really nice and makes every day food–just one reason why I like her. Doesn’t this pizza sound delish?}

11. Soft Pretzels from Sugar Crafter {Tracy has more than just sweets on her site! Go check it out! I love her clean layout.}

12. Spicy Steak from Bell’alimento {Steak is always good man food, right? Also, Paula is the reason I buy Nutella at Costco!}

13. Sausage and Mushroom ‘Pizza’ Soup from Bright Bakes {Cathy always makes me smile with her comments and twitter updates! Plus, she makes some serious bread!}

14. Cornbread Waffle Chili Stacks from Fab Frugal Food {Donna’s son is one of my Husband’s best friends and once Gord and I got married, I met Donna. She is a culinary genius and has a bunch of cookbooks out. I am in awe constantly at her work ethic! I have yet to meet Anne, but I think she’s super nice too! :)}

15. Spicy Black Bean Dip with Roasted Red and Chipotle Peppers from Cookin’ Canuck {I love Dara and her blog for so many reasons! But, mostly because she’s Canadian and it makes me happy that her site has a maple leaf on it!}

16. Chicken with Coconut-Lime Peanut Sauce from Family Fresh Cooking {I love coming to Marla’s site and finding tons of guilt free recipes!}

17. Cookie Sticks from Amanda’s Cookin {Amanda’s posts are always so mouth watering and alyways pretty easy to make!}

18. Slow Cooker Island BBQ Chicken from Perry’s Plate {I LOVE this girl! I found her on Tasty Kitchen and after chatting a bit, turns out we have a lot in common…. needless to say we became fast friends! I love ALL her recipes}

19. Black Bean Mexican Pizza from Good Life Eats {Looking at Katie’s site makes me so hungry all the time!}

20. Chicken Cakes from Bread and Putter {Going to this site makes me smile! I just love Jennifer’s writing style! She always brightens my day!}

Alright, I suppose 20 is enough for now! If you need more blog recommendations, I know of plenty I didn’t mention, so email me or send me a message to inquire further!

NOW! Onto some pie!

With Saturday being World Nutella Day and February being Pie Month, I thought it was only fitting to throw the two of these together for a smashing delicious and decadent dessert.This pie is so easy to make too! It sounds and looks sort of fancy, but it was really simple:

I first made and baked off my empty pie shell. Then, I made a chocolate and nutella pudding that I filled my pie shell with and refrigerated until set. Then I just topped it all off with lots of cream! Hello! It is Nutella CREAM Pie after all! And voila! Your pie is finished! It takes a little waiting time, but it is worth it!

This is creamy and dreamy and not too sweet! My husband thought it tasted less sweet and nutella-y because of the cream, but I liked it just fine. I think it’s necessary that I mention Gordon doesn’t like whipped cream.{I know right? Who doesn’t like whipped cream?!} That may have thrown him off a bit.  Besides him being a little weird about whipped cream, my daughter and I successfully ate 2 slices! If you like things really sweet, then up the sugar and nutella by 1/4 cup and add an extra tablespoon of cornstarch in just to make sure it sets!

So, be sure to celebrate World Nutella Day and/or the Super Bowl with some Nutella Cream Pie! Yum! Have a great weekend, folks!

Nutella Cream Pie
yield: 8-10 servings
Print This Recipe Print This Recipe


1-9 inch pie shell, blind baked

for the filling-
2 cups whole milk
1/4 cup unsweetened cocoa, sifted
1/2 cup granulated sugar
1/4 cup cornstarch
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1/2 cup nutella

for the cream-
1 cup heavy cream
1/4 cup granulated sugar
1/2 tablespoon corn starch*
1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract

In a medium {cold} saucepan, stir cocoa, sugar and cornstarch together. Slowly whisk cold milk into dry ingredients to prevent lumps from forming. Place on medium high heat and whisk continually. Once pudding starts to come to a bubble, boil for 15-30 seconds or until noticeably very thick {keep whisking!}. Remove from heat and whisk in vanilla and nutella until smooth. Pour into pie shell and cover with plastic wrap directly on filling. Refrigerate 2-3 hours or until filling is set and plastic wrap comes off clean.

In a stand mixer, whip all ingredients together until stiff peaks form. Spread cream over pie and serve cold.

*Corn starch acts as a stabilizer for cream, so if you are making this pie in advance, I’d recommend adding the cornstarch so your cream stays firm. If you are serving immediately, then the cornstarch is optional.


Read more of our favorites



Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. LOVE the pie! Great list of recipes too! Thanks for including our pizza:) Have a great weekend!

  2. Aw, I love you, too, girl! Great round-up — thanks for including one of mine! That pie looks amazing. I love that you got pie and Nutella into one dish. Way to multi-task! It looks so great. I think tomorrow should be turned into a bank holiday.

  3. Aww, you are too sweet!! Thank you for the mention! Also, OMG that pie…I swoon. 🙂

  4. Nutella cream pie? seriously? AMAZING!
    My dad would have been all over that!!…….I miss making yummy desserts for him. My Dad would eat anything I made, but cream pies were one of his favorites!!

    Thanks so much for the shout out too! {wink}

  5. THanks so much for this recipe! My husband is crazy about Nutella (esp since he can’t eat peanut butter) so I think I will be making this for Valentines Day!

  6. Thanks for the shout-out! You are too kind! 🙂

    And this pie looks great!! Anything with Nutella. Mmmmmmm.

  7. Nutella CREAM PIE?! That is positively BRILLIANT!

  8. Thanks for the mention, Lauren. Your pie looks delicious!

    • Yes! Another fabulous way to use Nutella! Yours looks delish!

      Thanks for the shout out!

  9. Such a sweet post! Thanks for including my chili in your roundup and the sweet comments! How did I not know it was pie month. Your pie looks fabulous!

  10. Fabulous round-up, and I love the Nutella Cream Pie. Will be adding my Guinness Truffles rolled in crushed pretzels to later today or tomorrow for Super Bowl sunday fare.

  11. You are so sweet to include my Coconut Chicken recipe 🙂 Love this round up & that Nutella pie sounds fabulous!

  12. I absolutely love nutella, and this pie looks amazing!

  13. Hey, great minds think alike! I made a Nutella Cream Tart for World Nutella Day. Your pics make me want to try your version too! Thumbs up!

  14. I’m so glad I tried this recipe!! I never make half a recipe of anything so rather than have second pie crust get abandoned in the fridge, I made this most exquisite pie!! Just so amazing and I can’t wait to introduce it to all the chocoholics in my family!! 8c)

  15. This is definately a pie I will have to make!



  1. Tweets that mention Super Bowl Recipes & Nutella Cream Pie! - Lauren's Latest -- - [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Sally Mann, thebellanutella, Lauren Brennan, Lauren Brennan, Lauren Brennan and others. Lauren…
  2. Nutella Cream Pie | bella nutella - [...] Contributed by: Lauren’s Latest Nutella Cream Pie [...]
  3. Nutella Pudding with Chantilly Cream and a Cookie Crust | bakerisbetter - […] […]